Claims & Payments AARP – Hartford Claims: 877-805-9918 Payments: 877-805-9918 Aflac Claims: 800-992-3522 Payments: 800-992-3522 Allstate Claims: 800-669-2214 Payments: 800-901-1732 American Modern Claims: 800-375-2075 Payments: 800-543-2644 Anthem Claims: 833-959-1531 Payments: 833-959-1531 Berkshire Hathaway Claims: 800-356-5750 Payments: 877-680-2442 Blue Cross Blue Shield Claims: 833-901-1364 Payments: 833-901-1364 Bristol West Claims: 800-274-7865 Payments: 888-888-0080 Burns & Wilcox Claims: 412-922-0104 Payments: 412-922-0104 Celina Claims: 800-231-2318 Payments: 855-586-2911 CNA Surety Claims: 877-672-6115 Payments: 800-331-6053 Dairyland Claims: 800-334-0090 Payments: 800-334-0090 Donegal Claims: 800 877-9006 Payments: 800-877-0600, press 8 Encompass Claims: 800-588-7400 Payments: 866-430-2916 Foremost Claims: 800-237-6136 Payments: 800-532-4221 Grange Claims: 800-445-3030 Payments: 800-425-1100 Hagerty Claims: 888-220-9565 Payments: 800-762-2628 The Hartford Claims: 860-547-5000 Payments: 860-547-5000 Kemper Claims: 888-253-7834 Payments: 800-456-0448 Merchants Insurance Group Claims: 800-462-1077 Payments: 800-462-1077 National General Claims: 800-468-3466 Payments: 877-468-3466 Nationwide Claims: 800-421-3535 Payments: 888-891-0867 Ohio Fair Plan Claims: 800-282-1772 Payments: 800-282-1772 Progessive Claims 800-776-4737 Payments 800-888-7764 Safeco Insurance Claims: 800-332-3226 Payments: 888-726-3260 State Auto Claims: 877-722-5246 Payments: 833-724-3577 Travelers Insurance Claims: 800-252-4633 Payments: 877-878-2468 Utica First Claims: 800-456–4556 Payments: 800-456–4556 Utica National Insurance Group Claims: 800-216-1420 Payments: 800-598-8422 Western Reserve Group Claims: 800-362-0426 Payments: 800-362-0426
